Am I asking too much?

I think he looks worth it...I'd check him out for sure. I'd say if you don't get any more intrest in the next month or so (longer if you don't have to sell him RIGHT AWAY) lower the price to $2,000. He looks like a very nice horse for the price, only minor conformation flaw I saw was his back is a little long...but I have seen worse (I am not good with conformation in the legs so I will let others comment on that). I guess the reason you ar getting more offers is because of the economy :P